Talk:Imperial Admiral: Difference between revisions

Line 29:

#During the [[Covenant Civil War]] [[Xytan 'Jar Wattinree]] combined two seperate fleets to fight Covenant forces. He did so without a promotion in rank as being in rebellion against the Covenant and the its [[Prophets]].

#On page 239 of [[Halo:Ghost Of Onyx]] there is a reference to the '''former''' Supreme Commander, "This happened before the '''former''' supreme commander of fleet of particular justice.". The MS dictionary states that Former is defined as, ''Former-Having been something: having had the name or status specified during an earlier period''. Therefore Xytan 'Jar Wattinree was a former Supreme Commander and his rank never changed because as shown above he could not have been given a promotion by the Covenant as he was in rebellion against the Covenant and the its [[Prophets]]

:#This is a logical fallacy; you're saying that since there is insufficient proof to their being different, there is proof to their being the same.

:#Why would he need a promotion in rank? If he is, as the page says, the leader of the ''entire'' Covenant fleet, he can put together the ''entire'' Covenant fleet if he wants to.

:#What are you dribbling about? If he's called a ''former'' Supreme Commander at one point but '''not''' called a former Imperial Admiral at another time, then it's more likely that he's a former Supreme Commander because he used to be a Supreme Commander, but is not a ''former'' Imperial Admiral because he ''is'' '''at this moment''' an Imperial Admiral, because he was promoted. '''[[User:Guesty-Persony-Thingy|GüéßŁ¥]]-[[User talk:Guesty-Persony-Thingy|∏éҐ∫øñ¥]]-[[Special:Contributions/Guesty-Persony-Thingy|†ħîИg¥]]''' 21:57, 5 April 2007 (UTC)

==Votes for MERGE==

@@ Line 29: / Line 29: @@
 #During the [[Covenant Civil War]] [[Xytan 'Jar Wattinree]] combined two seperate fleets to fight Covenant forces.  He did so without a promotion in rank as being in rebellion against the Covenant and the its [[Prophets]].
 #On page 239 of [[Halo:Ghost Of Onyx]] there is a reference to the '''former''' Supreme Commander, "This happened before the '''former''' supreme commander of fleet of particular justice.".  The MS dictionary states that Former is defined as, ''Former-Having been something: having had the name or status specified during an earlier period''.   Therefore Xytan 'Jar Wattinree was a former Supreme Commander and his rank never changed because as shown above he could not have been given a promotion by the Covenant as he was in rebellion against the Covenant and the its [[Prophets]]
+:#This is a logical fallacy; you're saying that since there is insufficient proof to their being different, there is proof to their being the same.
+:#Why would he need a promotion in rank? If he is, as the page says, the leader of the ''entire'' Covenant fleet, he can put together the ''entire'' Covenant fleet if he wants to.
+:#What are you dribbling about? If he's called a ''former'' Supreme Commander at one point but '''not''' called a former Imperial Admiral at another time, then it's more likely that he's a former Supreme Commander because he used to be a Supreme Commander, but is not a ''former'' Imperial Admiral because he ''is'' '''at this moment''' an Imperial Admiral, because he was promoted. '''[[User:Guesty-Persony-Thingy|<font color="#000000">G</font><font color="#770000"><sup>ü</sup></font><font color="#cc0000">é</font><font color="#ff0000"><sub>ß</sub></font><font color="#ff3333">Ł</font><font color="#ff6666"><sup>¥</sup></font>]]-[[User talk:Guesty-Persony-Thingy|<font color="#9999ff">∏</font><font color="#6666ff"><sub>é</sub></font><font color="#3333ff">Ґ</font><font color="#0000ff"><sup>∫</sup></font><font color="#0000cc">ø</font><font color="#000066"><sub>ñ</sub></font><font color="#000000">¥</font>]]-[[Special:Contributions/Guesty-Persony-Thingy|<font color="#000000"><sup>†</sup></font><font color="#007700">ħ</font><font color="#00cc00"><sub>î</sub></font><font color="#00ff00">И</font><font color="#44ff44"><sup>g</sup></font><font color="#99ff99">¥</font>]]''' 21:57, 5 April 2007 (UTC)
 ==Votes for MERGE==