Talk:Shiva-class nuclear missile: Difference between revisions
From Halopedia, the Halo wiki
(Yield is too small) |
|||
| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
The current yield of only 30 to 80 megatons doesn’t make that much sense. For one thing Archer Missles would probably be equipped with a 30 megaton HAVOK warhead for the purpose of anti-ship warfare and it takes hundreds of them to just down the shields on a Covenant Carrier. | The current yield of only 30 to 80 megatons doesn’t make that much sense. For one thing Archer Missles would probably be equipped with a 30 megaton HAVOK warhead for the purpose of anti-ship warfare and it takes hundreds of them to just down the shields on a Covenant Carrier. | ||
There's no evidence that Archer missiles use HAVOKs, if they did then the 30 megaton mine field wouldn't have even been considered, especially since Archers are direct detonation missiles. Speaking of HORNET mines, for those 14 mines to be used over three Shivas then logically a Shiva would probably be somewhere around 140 megatons. | |||
That said, I'm not sure where the 80 megaton Shiva yield came from. I think it was from a quote where it was stated that Dr. Hasley stood in a base that could withstand such an explosion. | |||
Revision as of 16:15, August 3, 2008
too small
while I understand why they HAVOK mines would be around 30megatons, it would seem that a nuke designed to fight ships well over 1km in length, and govered by a couple of meters of titanium armor would have more punch to it.
sources?
where did the 30 megaton yeild come from?
Yield is too small
The current yield of only 30 to 80 megatons doesn’t make that much sense. For one thing Archer Missles would probably be equipped with a 30 megaton HAVOK warhead for the purpose of anti-ship warfare and it takes hundreds of them to just down the shields on a Covenant Carrier.
There's no evidence that Archer missiles use HAVOKs, if they did then the 30 megaton mine field wouldn't have even been considered, especially since Archers are direct detonation missiles. Speaking of HORNET mines, for those 14 mines to be used over three Shivas then logically a Shiva would probably be somewhere around 140 megatons.
That said, I'm not sure where the 80 megaton Shiva yield came from. I think it was from a quote where it was stated that Dr. Hasley stood in a base that could withstand such an explosion.