Talk:Halo Encyclopedia (2022 edition): Difference between revisions
From Halopedia, the Halo wiki
(Created page with "==Regarding Bonita Stone 'error'== I'm curious why the Encyclopedia (written first) is being called out for an error in Spartan Stone's birth year when it was Rubicon Protocol that didn't conform to the preexisting information. While reviewing, there was a lot of Halo Infinite game data still in flux but we tried to get things right with last-minute edits where we could. We couldn't anticipate a novel would later contradict the Encyclopedia but it seems the mistake shoul...") |
BaconShelf (talk | contribs) |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==Regarding Bonita Stone 'error'== | ==Regarding Bonita Stone 'error'== | ||
I'm curious why the Encyclopedia (written first) is being called out for an error in Spartan Stone's birth year when it was Rubicon Protocol that didn't conform to the preexisting information. While reviewing, there was a lot of Halo Infinite game data still in flux but we tried to get things right with last-minute edits where we could. We couldn't anticipate a novel would later contradict the Encyclopedia but it seems the mistake should be written into a page on Rubicon Protocol instead of here. -[[User:ScaleMaster117|ScaleMaster117]] ([[User talk:ScaleMaster117|talk]]) 07:01, May 13, 2024 (EDT) | I'm curious why the Encyclopedia (written first) is being called out for an error in Spartan Stone's birth year when it was Rubicon Protocol that didn't conform to the preexisting information. While reviewing, there was a lot of Halo Infinite game data still in flux but we tried to get things right with last-minute edits where we could. We couldn't anticipate a novel would later contradict the Encyclopedia but it seems the mistake should be written into a page on Rubicon Protocol instead of here. -[[User:ScaleMaster117|ScaleMaster117]] ([[User talk:ScaleMaster117|talk]]) 07:01, May 13, 2024 (EDT) | ||
:This is a good point! I'll get this information moved over shortly (though I do think it's worth keeping a note on this page that the info in the book was later contradicted by Rubicon, in case anyone else comes looking). However, I do think there is a valid point in there that 25 seems somewhat young for Kovan to have had the kind of career that led to her becoming a Spartan - even putting aside any issues with the Rubicon Protocol contradiction (but that's a more subjective view that's probably not suitable for this sort of page). [[User:BaconShelf|<span style="color:green;">BaconShelf</span>]] <span style="font-size:90%">([[User:BaconShelf|talk]])</span> 07:09, May 13, 2024 (EDT) | |||
Latest revision as of 06:11, May 13, 2024
Regarding Bonita Stone 'error'[edit]
I'm curious why the Encyclopedia (written first) is being called out for an error in Spartan Stone's birth year when it was Rubicon Protocol that didn't conform to the preexisting information. While reviewing, there was a lot of Halo Infinite game data still in flux but we tried to get things right with last-minute edits where we could. We couldn't anticipate a novel would later contradict the Encyclopedia but it seems the mistake should be written into a page on Rubicon Protocol instead of here. -ScaleMaster117 (talk) 07:01, May 13, 2024 (EDT)
- This is a good point! I'll get this information moved over shortly (though I do think it's worth keeping a note on this page that the info in the book was later contradicted by Rubicon, in case anyone else comes looking). However, I do think there is a valid point in there that 25 seems somewhat young for Kovan to have had the kind of career that led to her becoming a Spartan - even putting aside any issues with the Rubicon Protocol contradiction (but that's a more subjective view that's probably not suitable for this sort of page). BaconShelf (talk) 07:09, May 13, 2024 (EDT)