Editing Talk:Dead or Alive 4
From Halopedia, the Halo wiki
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
| Latest revision | Your text | ||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
No. It doesn't have a direct relationship to the halo series. it has an indirect relationship. barely. 458 is non-canon, she can have a page, but not the game that she is in. If this is a Halo wiki, then the only games or materials with pages in it should be Halo related. And don't just delete a delete nomination without discussing why you think that way. What kind of example does that set Manticore? Abuse of power, along with applying personal thoughts to halo-wikia pages, and editing without the consent of the Halopedian community. I ,sir, am appalled. Now if you think otherwise, (which I assume you do) I would be happy to allow you to attempt to persuade my thinking. But dont undermine the rules to do what oyu want. Otherwise a large point of the Halo wiki community would be useless. [[User:Spartan 107|Spartan 107]] 00:25, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | No. It doesn't have a direct relationship to the halo series. it has an indirect relationship. barely. 458 is non-canon, she can have a page, but not the game that she is in. If this is a Halo wiki, then the only games or materials with pages in it should be Halo related. And don't just delete a delete nomination without discussing why you think that way. What kind of example does that set Manticore? Abuse of power, along with applying personal thoughts to halo-wikia pages, and editing without the consent of the Halopedian community. I ,sir, am appalled. Now if you think otherwise, (which I assume you do) I would be happy to allow you to attempt to persuade my thinking. But dont undermine the rules to do what oyu want. Otherwise a large point of the Halo wiki community would be useless. [[User:Spartan 107|Spartan 107]] 00:25, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | ||
| Line 14: | Line 13: | ||
'''Against:''' | '''Against:''' | ||
*Most of the article concerns Nicole, who has obtained a personal mention from Bungie. While not canon, she's also relatively well-known. <span title="I am not an admin.">Çya</span>, [[ | *Most of the article concerns Nicole, who has obtained a personal mention from Bungie. While not canon, she's also relatively well-known. <span title="I am not an admin.">Çya</span>, [[w:c:halo:User:Mouse among men|<font color="black">M</font>]][[w:c:halo:User talk:Mouse among men|<font color="black"><span title="Yes, it's Møuse. SJ, I'm looking at you.">ø</span></font>]][[Special:Contributions/Mouse among men|<font color="black">u</font>]][[w:c:halo:Halopedia:Parasite of Halopedia|<font color="black">s</font>]][[w:c:halo:User:Mouse among men/Sandbox|<font color="black">e</font>]] 01:29, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | ||
*The [[Apocalypso]] universe is a '''''highly''''' notable piece of the Halo universe even if it is not perfectly canon. Review the similar debate regarding deletion at [[Talk:i love bees|talk:I Love Bees]]. --<b>[[User:Dragonclaws|<font color="#4D56B1">Dragon<font color="#F28500">c</font>laws</font>]]<sup>([[User talk:Dragonclaws|<font color="#4D56B1">talk</font>]])</sup></b> 01:57, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | *The [[Apocalypso]] universe is a '''''highly''''' notable piece of the Halo universe even if it is not perfectly canon. Review the similar debate regarding deletion at [[Talk:i love bees|talk:I Love Bees]]. --<b>[[User:Dragonclaws|<font color="#4D56B1">Dragon<font color="#F28500">c</font>laws</font>]]<sup>([[User talk:Dragonclaws|<font color="#4D56B1">talk</font>]])</sup></b> 01:57, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | ||
| Line 20: | Line 19: | ||
* Nicole isn't even mentioned until the last paragraph! How is most if this article concerning Nicole!? Besides, she has her page, and I am cool with that. her being in dead or alive 4 doesnt mean that that game deserves a page. [[User:Spartan 107|Spartan 107]] 02:41, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | * Nicole isn't even mentioned until the last paragraph! How is most if this article concerning Nicole!? Besides, she has her page, and I am cool with that. her being in dead or alive 4 doesnt mean that that game deserves a page. [[User:Spartan 107|Spartan 107]] 02:41, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | ||
**It explains the game's relevancy to Halo, something that the Wikipedia page would not do. We have similar pages that describe real world elements (e.g. metals), and then go into their relevancy. --<b>[[User:Dragonclaws|<font color="#4D56B1">Dragon<font color="#F28500">c</font>laws</font>]]<sup>([[User talk:Dragonclaws|<font color="#4D56B1">talk</font>]])</sup></b> 03:44, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | **It explains the game's relevancy to Halo, something that the Wikipedia page would not do. We have similar pages that describe real world elements (e.g. metals), and then go into their relevancy. --<b>[[User:Dragonclaws|<font color="#4D56B1">Dragon<font color="#F28500">c</font>laws</font>]]<sup>([[User talk:Dragonclaws|<font color="#4D56B1">talk</font>]])</sup></b> 03:44, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | ||
*I see to reason to why we must have a DOA4 Eracon. If anything should have an Eracon, it should be [[The Art of Halo]]. -- | *I see to reason to why we must have a DOA4 Eracon. If anything should have an Eracon, it should be [[The Art of Halo]]. --[[Image:BR55HB SR Battle Rifle.jpg|65px]] [[User:Blemo|<span style="color: steelblue; font-family: CarolusRomanFont; font-size: 10pt;">'''UNIT-X23'''</span>]] http://www.wikia.com/skins/common/progress-wheel.gif <small><sup>[[user talk:Blemo|<font color="royalblue">TALK</font>]]</sup></small> • <sub><small> [[Special:Contributions/Blemo|<font color="lightblue">CONTRIBUTIONS</font>]]</small></sub> • <sub><small><span class="plainlinks">[http://www.bungie.net/Stats/Halo3/Default.aspx?player=Blemo+23 <font color="teal">SERVICE RECORD</font>]</span></small></sub> • <sub><small><font color="olivedrab"><span style="font-weight: light;" title="''Loser''. noun -- Anyone that is dumb enough to stare at a message on someone's signature for no apparent reason. You reading this pretty much proves the point.">MESSAGE</span></font></small></sub> 04:01, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | ||
**Because some content comes from DOA4, and the era marks it as such. There's nothing to say The Art of Halo ''can't'' have one, and I'll work on it later when I get back to a computer with Photoshop if no one else has by then. --<b>[[User:Dragonclaws|<font color="#4D56B1">Dragon<font color="#F28500">c</font>laws</font>]]<sup>([[User talk:Dragonclaws|<font color="#4D56B1">talk</font>]])</sup></b> 04:05, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | **Because some content comes from DOA4, and the era marks it as such. There's nothing to say The Art of Halo ''can't'' have one, and I'll work on it later when I get back to a computer with Photoshop if no one else has by then. --<b>[[User:Dragonclaws|<font color="#4D56B1">Dragon<font color="#F28500">c</font>laws</font>]]<sup>([[User talk:Dragonclaws|<font color="#4D56B1">talk</font>]])</sup></b> 04:05, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | ||
*I'm not completely sure if this should be deleted or not. There is some relative Halo information, but this articles is very poorly written for a Halopedia article. The useful information is scattered and the other, unrelevant crap is everywhere else. I would vote for keeping it, only if it is revised and rewritten. [[User:TomX117|TomX117]] 15:40, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | *I'm not completely sure if this should be deleted or not. There is some relative Halo information, but this articles is very poorly written for a Halopedia article. The useful information is scattered and the other, unrelevant crap is everywhere else. I would vote for keeping it, only if it is revised and rewritten. [[User:TomX117|TomX117]] 15:40, 3 December 2007 (UTC) | ||
| Line 27: | Line 26: | ||
Well, over the years, my mind has changed and I am now against the article's inclusion. We've updated our standards regarding the "If it's mentioned it gets an article" rule with regard to food, shifting dozens of pointless articles like [[pizza]] and [[melon]] into one worthwhile [[List of food and drinks|list]], and ''Dead or Alive 4'' has even more tenuous connection to the ''Halo'' series. We have a [[list of outside references to the Halo series]] and articles about the Spartan [[Nicole-458]] and set [[Nassau Station]] exported from the ''Halo'' universe into the ''Dead or Alive'' universe. The latter two derive their notability from Bungie coming up with backstories for them and tying them into the ''[[i love bees]]'' plot, but ''Dead or Alive 4'', while relevant to the subjects of Nicole-485 and Nassau Station, is not of the ''Halo'' franchise anymore than the other games mentioned in the outside references list. The page itself should be deleted, and its information should be merged into appropriate articles. Any time the game itself need be mentioned, we can link offsite to Wikipedia. --<b>[[User:Dragonclaws|<font color="#800080">Dragon<font color="#DE397E">c</font>laws</font>]]<sup>([[User talk:Dragonclaws|<font color="#6600D8">talk</font>]])</sup></b> 14:03, 28 August 2012 (EDT) | Well, over the years, my mind has changed and I am now against the article's inclusion. We've updated our standards regarding the "If it's mentioned it gets an article" rule with regard to food, shifting dozens of pointless articles like [[pizza]] and [[melon]] into one worthwhile [[List of food and drinks|list]], and ''Dead or Alive 4'' has even more tenuous connection to the ''Halo'' series. We have a [[list of outside references to the Halo series]] and articles about the Spartan [[Nicole-458]] and set [[Nassau Station]] exported from the ''Halo'' universe into the ''Dead or Alive'' universe. The latter two derive their notability from Bungie coming up with backstories for them and tying them into the ''[[i love bees]]'' plot, but ''Dead or Alive 4'', while relevant to the subjects of Nicole-485 and Nassau Station, is not of the ''Halo'' franchise anymore than the other games mentioned in the outside references list. The page itself should be deleted, and its information should be merged into appropriate articles. Any time the game itself need be mentioned, we can link offsite to Wikipedia. --<b>[[User:Dragonclaws|<font color="#800080">Dragon<font color="#DE397E">c</font>laws</font>]]<sup>([[User talk:Dragonclaws|<font color="#6600D8">talk</font>]])</sup></b> 14:03, 28 August 2012 (EDT) | ||