Editing Talk:Covenant frigate

What happened? You had a picture of it before!--[[User:Leckgolo434|prophit of war]] 18:29, 18 November 2006 (UTC)
:[[User:RelentlessRecusant]] took it out on 01:24, 17 November 2006 -- [[User:Esemono|Esemono]] 02:48, 19 November 2006 (UTC)

== wrong size comparison ==

I have recently re-read halo the fall of reach and it is stated in chapter twelve that the UNSC frigate commonwealth engaged a covenant ship that was ''only a third the size of the commonwealth'' i checked the page on this wiki that is for the UNSC commonwealth and it states that the ship it engaged was a covenant frigate if this is so then why does the covenant frigate page state that covenant frigates are BIGGER that UNSC frigates whereas if i look at the 2 sources in conjunction (halpoedia article and book reference) i come to the conclusion that the information on the covenant frigate page should be amended. 
P.S im checking in case i missed something or am completely wrong.
thanks for reading.
*Hey, what's up? Wait, it says it is a ''frigate''? The {{UNSCShip|Commonwealth}} page then must be based on conjecture. I am taking the length from ''[[Halo: Ghosts of Onyx]]''. Cheers, '''[[User:RelentlessRecusant|<font color="red">Relentless</font>]][[User talk:RelentlessRecusant|<font color="blue">Recusant</font>]][[Image:Jedi_Order.jpg|20px]]''' 20:50, 25 November 2006 (UTC)
*Not too long ago the covi frigate size was different...thats what i was talking about...since you have changed the size my comment is obsolete. But it does leave the question-what kind of ship attacked UNSC commonwealth? a corvette perhaps? {{unsigned|62.253.128.15}}
I think that based on The Fall of Reach, that A frigate is only about 150 meters, captain keyes states this during his fight at Sigma Octanus -[[User:All Under Heaven|All Under Heaven]]
== Picture of covenant Frigate ==

That picture of the covenant frigate is not really a covenant frigate but a covenant cruiser. I look it up in a book called "The Art of Halo creating a video game" and I saw the same picture of the covenant frigate but it said it was a covenant cruiser not a covenant frigate. Its also not a covenant battlecruiser because it doesnt look like one so its a normal covenant cruiser in the book I said before.

== PICTURE?! ==
Okay SOMETHING needs to be done immediately. Never in the Halo Graphic Novel, from which the picture was taken, does it EVER say that the ship is in fact a frigate. This is a blatent fanon crossover. Come on people!!! Is this the kind of reputation Halopedia wants? Not only that, but The Art of Halo DOES in fact say a ship that JUST HAPPENS to look just like it is a type of cruiser. And as if you need any MORE evidence, Halo: First Strike describes a light cruiser as a "luminous manta ray". I would say the description fits this broad-wing ship. Please do something! I would myself if I wasn't so afraid of the flaming a-holes who are too proud of their work to admit they're wrong.
[[User talk:Nerfherder1428|Nerfherder1428]] 16:06, 11 August 2009 (UTC)